Concrete Tile Roof vs Asphalt Shingles

When deciding which type of roofing material to choose for your next housing, residential, or commercial project, it is imperative to know the benefits and drawbacks of various roof types. This will help you make a more informed decision about roofing materials.
While choosing asphalt shingles may seem better because of their popularity, you should remember that sometimes there may be better options than the most popular material for your specific needs.
Keep following the article below to find out which roofing material is best for your new roof.

Longevity

If you plan to enjoy a new roof with your family, longevity may matter more to you than if you plan to sell quickly.
Asphalt shingles are more prone to wear and tear over time than concrete roof tiles. In addition, asphalt shingle roofs crack and have flakes within them during times of extreme weather.
Contrasting with asphalt shingles, concrete tiles can last for many more years. In addition, concrete roof tiles need very little maintenance, have better structural integrity, and have more weather resistance.

Cost-Effectiveness

When deciding on roofing tiles, it is also important to keep budget in mind. If you have a limited budget to spend on roofing tiles, you may only be able to install asphalt shingles.
All roofing materials are usually sold and installed by the square, which means 100 square feet. The average cost to install asphalt shingles ranges between $65 and $80. Contrastingly, the cost of concrete roof tiles is a lot higher. This residential roofing costs somewhere between $120 and $250 per square.

Durability

When deciding on getting a roofing material, many homeowners want something that lasts a long time. This will prevent them from buying additional materials for continuous maintenance and provide a better structure to their house.
Concrete tile roofs are built to outlast asphalt shingle roofs. A concrete roof tile can easily last from 25 to 100 years. Although metal tends to last the longest, concrete tile roofs have lasted over 100 years.
On the other hand, an asphalt shingle roof can only last between 15 and 30 years. The longest-lasting asphalt shingles have improved thickness and style, as well as higher costs. Thicker shingles have a longer life compared to the standard three-tab roofing shingles.

Weight

An asphalt roof is much more lightweight than other roofing materials, including concrete tiles. Therefore, depending on the material, they can be installed on any roof. However, a concrete tile roof is very heavy. The exact weight depends on the type of concrete roofing tiles used. For example, some manufacturers now produce lightweight concrete roof tiles.
Any type of tile roof is heavier than a shingle roof. Therefore, ensuring that your roof deck is durable enough to handle a heavier roof, such as concrete tiles, is essential. If your roof cannot support something heavy, then a shingle roof is better for you.

Fire Resistance

It is further essential to ensure that your roof has good fire resistance. Many asphalt shingles on the market have earned a Class-A- fire resistance rating.
Concrete tiles absorb heat well, and many Class-A rated concrete roof tiles are available. However, similar to the case of metal roofing, it is vital that you choose roofing materials that provide the best heat protection.

Hail Resistance

Concrete tile roofs can handle all weather conditions, while asphalt shingles are more vulnerable to hail.

Wind Resistance

Asphalt shingles and concrete tiles have a different range of wind resistance. As a result, asphalt shingles are more prone to damage from high and strong winds.
In contrast, concrete roofing tiles have much higher wind resistance. This is so because a concrete roof tile can easily withstand high winds with speeds going up to 180mph.

Eco-Friendliness

With the world's growing trends towards being environmentally friendly, it is vital to install a new roof that helps the environment. Shingles have some environmental advantages, which make their manufacturing process more energy efficient and reduce energy costs.
Concrete tiles may be less eco-friendly to manufacture, but concrete tiles last a lot longer than shingles. Thus, upon installation, they end up in landfills less than shingles.

Energy Efficiency

Concrete tile roofing is a better option for installation if you want to become a more energy-efficient consumer.
Concrete tile roofing is installed to allow airflow under and through the tile. They have been rated far more energy efficient than an asphalt shingle roof.

Warranty

Warranty periods differ for shingle and tile roofs. In addition, the warranty for shingles varies by company. Concrete tile roofing comes in many more styles and has more warranty options, with Eagle Roofing Products offering a lifetime warranty.

Frequently Asked Questions

Having provided you with enough information about both types of roofing materials, we will now begin answering some FAQs.

Which is better: concrete tiles or shingles?

Concrete Tile Roof vs. Asphalt Shingles is an often debated question. Both have pros and cons—these need to be thoroughly analyzed while keeping your needs in mind when deciding what to buy.

What are the disadvantages of tile roofs?

Tile roofs come with a few disadvantages that are as follows:

• can be brittle
• tend to get dirty easily
• high cost
• tricky to install
• unsuitable for all roof slopes/weight

Conclusion

Summing up the article, it is essential to remember that whether you use shingles or roof tiles, you must consult a professional roofer before replacing one with the other.
What you choose must provide you with the required impact resistance, durability from cold or hot climates, the optimum amount of water absorption, and other necessary requirements.

Roofing is a Long Term Decision. Consider Value Over Cost.
Let the experts at Affordable Roofing Systems help you find the right solution for your new roof. Contact our headquarters at (813) 542 8462 for more information about our wide range of roofing services and roofing material options, or schedule an appointment for your roof project.